Well, we (once again) fell into the rut of not blogging. Since we know that you all love our wit and wisdom and have been sinking into a pit of despair in the wake of our virtual absence, we are (once again) making a blogging comeback. So here it is: my belated review of our outing to Sanford.
To celebrate our first wedding anniversary, Craig and I made reservations at Chef Sanford DiMotto’s top-tier establishment, Sanford. Sanford offers a seven-course chef’s choice tasting meal on weekdays, so we opted to go on our actual anniversary, a Monday. Set in an East Side neighborhood near the site of Points East Pub, which hosted our post-wedding rock party, Sanford’s atmosphere is simple, modern, and inviting. Upon our arrival, we were greeted by excellent service, which continued throughout the evening. The restaurant no doubt has excellent service at all times, but I am sure our being the only table in the restaurant didn’t hurt.
We began the evening with an amuse-bouche, which is a small bite before the meal begins. Sadly, I cannot recall what our amuse-bouche was, but you can rest assured that it was fabulous. We then moved on to the seven courses. All except the sixth were served with wine pairings.
First Course: American Sturgeon Caviar and Smoked Salmon, Buckwheat Dumplings, Scallion Cauliflower Craig enjoyed this course far more than I did. While the dish was perfectly executed, I finally had to conclude that I simply do not like smoked salmon, but the buckwheat dumplings were warm and scrumptious.
Second Course: Lobster and Roasted Pumpkin Ravioli, Sage Brown Butter. I would never have thought to pair pumpkin with lobster, but somehow it worked. It was rich without being heavy, and the pumpkin was perfect for winter. It was paired with a demi-sec wine, which was the perfect complement to the dish and really brought out the toasty flavor.
Third Course: Grilled Sea Scallop and Octopus, Chorizo Stew. Count this as another “I never would’ve thought to do that” dish, which is why I’m not a chef of…anything. Craig and I are Top Chef addicts, and for several weeks in a row, it seemed that scallops played a large part in each episode. Well, now I know why. I had never had a scallop like this – large, succulent, and perfectly cooked. The octopus served with with the chorizo made the accompaniment a tad bit chewy, but the flavor was delicious.
Fourth Course: Slow Roasted Pork Shoulder with Seared Escarole, Burnt Orange Vinaigrette. Is there anything better than tender, slow-cooked pork? I didn’t think so. The orange sauce was warm and fruity and fabulous.
Fifth Course: Asian BBQ Striploin of Beef with Grilled Baby Bok Choy and Thai Green Curry Sauce. This dish was incredibly exciting. I believe that this was the first time I’d ever had rare beef, and I am converted. I have seen the light. A good piece of beef should be eaten rare. The curry sauce was not overly spicy, so it highlighted the flavor of the beef rather than masked it.
Sixth Course: Crave Brothers Sweet Cream Mascarpone with Poached Pear and Walnut Confit. This was described to us as a “transitional course” between the savory and the sweet, but if we hadn’t known a seventh course was coming, this would have made a fabulous dessert on its own. Sweet, fruity, toasty, and best of all, it made use of local ingredients – yum!
Seventh Course: Bitter-Sweet Hawaiin Vintage Intentional Chocolate Tart. Funny story about this course: the waiter brought us a decorative plate to celebrate our anniversary. It had Happy 1st Anniversary written in caramel and was decorated with chocolate and raspberry sauce. There were also some berries and whipped cream. We expected that the dessert course was to follow it shortly, but it took longer than we expected. So as we sat there, we began to wonder if that – the drizzling of sweet sauces and two dollops of whipped cream – was the dessert course. By this time, we’ve also had five glasses of wine and are feeling pretty buzzed, so although it seemed odd, we figured the restaurant knew what it was doing. Finally, our chocolate tarts arrived, and holy moly, was it the best chocolate I’ve ever had! For over a month, I’ve been describing this chocolate tart as so good that it made me want to divorce Craig just so that I could marry the tart and have its little chocolate babies. This course was served with port, which was another first for me. The smooth, warm, spicy taste of it was the perfect complement to the chocolate.
Overall, our Sanford experience was top-notch. The food was made with the finest of ingredients and artfully prepared. Best of all, the servings were reasonable sizes; despite eating seven courses complete with wine pairings, we left full and satisfied but not stuffed and miserable. At $85 per person for the chef’s surprise and $40 per person for the wine pairings (plus tax and tip for the excellent service), it is not a cheap night. But if you have a special occasion, we highly recommend celebrating it with a meal at Sanford.